Should Bots Deliver Free Speech?

How are courts going to address free-expression rights for the artificially intelligent communicators? This sort of conversation is coming forth. And this may push the Supreme Court into doing something they have avoided: defining who is and is not a journalist. So the question comes: Should Bots Deliver Free Speech? Find out below:

What’s cooking?

For about half a century, the US legal system has been living a double life. On one hand, the Supreme Court has held that journalists do not have greater or lesser rights than other citizens. On the other, the lower courts have in general ignored the laws and let stand numerous laws or privileges providing journalists special protection.

Free reign of Journalism?

These laws include the qualified First Amendment- on the basis of reporter’s privilege in some federal jurisdictions and fee waivers in FOI statutes. Most of the laws and privileges had been devised before the Web was made available to the public. The case law is inconsistent while applying these protections to online. The journo-specific measures had been useful at times, to the citizen publishers- bloggers, message-board posters, social-media commenters. These people had to face the same legal difficulties that traditional journalists have throughout the years. The list includes defamation and privacy claims, efforts for compelling disclosure of these sources. Should Bots Deliver Free Speech?

As years have gone by, state and the federal courts attempted to use a variety of approaches for defining journalism and who exactly is a journalist. There are state shield laws providing varying levels of protection to journalists from being forced to reveal the sources. And the citizen publishers have also invoked the shield laws. It varies significantly in the definition of who they protect. Should Bots Deliver Free Speech?

The burning question:

Where do bots come in? Networked technologies are challenging journalists for distinguishing their work from countless other types of news flooding the virtual spaces. These non-human entities contain the potential of muddying the waters even more. Courts will have to explore if AI communicators have the right to be a publisher and whether bots deserve journalistic protections.

Bots being better journalists?

Citizen publishers make for a good comparison. They fare best when the work can be understood as a public good. It is something generally informative or may even be related to a matter of public concern. Courts have taken into consideration the publishers’ practices. Was the work original? Does it include a source? Some courts have gone onto scrutinize the personal characteristics. Has the publisher ever been to any journalism school? Is he/she currently working for any news organization?

If the courts shift their focus to the publisher, then AI communicators will find it difficult for receiving journalistic protections. On the other hand, if the courts focus on what’s being published, then AI communicators stand a better chance to succeed. Of course, the content has to be seen as public good. You are reading, “Should Bots Deliver Free Speech?”.

Although giving free speech to bots may sound shocking, a court decision in their favor can benefit news organizations. Quite a few news organizations have published AI-constructed stories over the years. Many of these stories can be taken to be a public good and so, can receive journalistic legal protections. The issues get a bit complex in the context of fake news and clickbait. So, Should Bots Deliver Free Speech?

If you remember the recent elections in the US and the United Kingdom- then you will be able to remember the flooding of fake news by bots. There were many false and misleading contents published in this time which cannot be seen as public good. So, we have to question, what’s human about journalism? Can a bot programmer invoke a journalistic shield law and protect her program’s code that includes the sources used to construct the news? And if a bot files FOIA requests, then must it be exempt from the fees as it tends to scrape the data and publish it in tweets or on a blog?

Has the time come to take an action? Should Bots Deliver Free Speech? Leave a comment below and let us know what you think.

Advertisement

spot_img

7 Reasons This Viral...

📢 As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying...

Jaishankar meets senior Japanese...

In a significant step forward for Indo-Pacific diplomacy, External...

Why Viral Kitchen Gadgets...

📢 As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying...

How does a raccoon...

Raccoons are ubiquitous across both rural woodlands and bustling...

We Tested Viral Kitchen...

📢 As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying...

Brad Pitt and Ines...

Hollywood royalty made a stylish statement in Los Angeles...

7 Reasons This Viral Kitchen Gadgets Is Worth Every Single Penny

📢 As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.If you had told me six months ago that a single purchase would change how...

Jaishankar meets senior Japanese leaders; discusses deeper strategic, economic ties

In a significant step forward for Indo-Pacific diplomacy, External Affairs Minister S. Jaishankar met with senior Japanese leaders in Tokyo to deliberate on enhancing...

Why Viral Kitchen Gadgets Is Currently Breaking the Internet

📢 As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.I stumbled across this while desperately trying to fix a recurring problem in my routine....

How does a raccoon act with rabies?

Raccoons are ubiquitous across both rural woodlands and bustling suburban neighborhoods. While these masked foragers are generally cautious and nocturnal, their close proximity to...

We Tested Viral Kitchen Gadgets Here Is What You Must Know

📢 As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.There comes a point when you realise that tolerating a frustrating situation is costing you...

Brad Pitt and Ines De Ramon walk ‘The Further Mis-Adventures of Cliff Booth’ premiere red carpet hand in hand

Hollywood royalty made a stylish statement in Los Angeles as Oscar-winning actor Brad Pitt arrived hand in hand with his partner, jewelry designer Inés...

Why Viral Kitchen Gadgets Is Currently Breaking the Internet

📢 As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.Most products in this category disappoint within weeks. Cheap materials, vague instructions, and results that...

US and rivals spar over next UN boss as race lurches towards deadline

According to a report by Al Jazeera, diplomatic tensions among global powers have intensified as the United Nations nears the deadline to select its...

Why Viral Kitchen Gadgets Is Currently Breaking the Internet

📢 As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.If you had told me six months ago that a single purchase would change how...